GPO not replicating to other DC

Hello,

I have 2 Server 2008 R2 vms (VMware esxi 5.1 U1) running as DCs.  When I create a new GPO on the PDC emulator and then open GP management console on the other DC (targeted at itself not the PDC, the object is there but the configuration is missing and I get the error "The system cannot find the file specified."  This is only for newly created GPOs, all my GPOs older than a month or so, work just fine.

DCdiag, dfsdiag, repadmin /syncall, all run without generating any errors.  I'm not sure where else to look or what troubleshooting to do.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.